Showing posts with label arena of change. Show all posts
Showing posts with label arena of change. Show all posts

Monday, 7 October 2013

How a River Runs - Final Course Reflection



When I am asked to name my river, e.g.as part of my mihi, I acknowledge the Waimakariri. It is a river that has so many different moods and aspects and I have engaged with it in very many of them. When I think about the whole of this course, there is a direct metaphoric relationship to a river and its journey to the sea. Each of the courses in the PG Dip have flowed in quite different ways, and mix at the end in the sea that is our educational practice and the relationship to all the other learning opportunities in our lives.

Direction: From the start we were provided with excellent direction via the course site. At the same time as our lecturers were giving us a detailed outline of the course, it was clear that as postgraduate students, we were to determine our own direction of study for assessment.

Denali National Park, Alaska


Flow: To begin with, I did not understand how the course would develop. l gradually learned the relevance of each aspect of the content, and was then able to settle in and flow through the exercises and readings. There were starts and stops for me as various other parts of life cut in, but I maintained engagement and was able to begin incorporation of what I was learning in my everyday work context.

Arthurs Pass


Depth: What illustrates depth the most is the impact on my practice that aspects of this course have given. In particular, the benchmarking and the scenario planning which were immediately applied to current projects. To start with, I found the ecological perspective really difficult, but rereading and getting the idea that it is actually not about ecology has permitted me to see how useful it is sitting alongside the arena of change. I had always believed that I operate within a tightly influenced and related world, this gave me a different way to view the way those influences could be incorporated. The river is deep and offers up its secrets gradually and only after effort.

Whanganui

Breadth: Just as a river can at times be wider, and at others, narrower, so it was with the technology requirements in this course. Changes with digital technology in education meant embracing the new. For me, that began with establishing a blog site, moved to engagement with mindmapping software, and, with the widest possible breadth I could cope with, into a mOOC, using wikieducator. I had to give up my reliance on my mobile devices which run on Apple software, and remember that I was part of a wider group - it was no longer all about me and what worked for me, but about what would work for the whole world. Now, I am happy that we had to blog, and really value the tangible record of my learning and my reactions to it.

Avon


Season: The expected amount of work in this course really surprised me. In hindsight, I had probably floated a bit in some of the other papers, but the realisation of what I needed to do to in order to engage and implement the learning led me to negotiate for my study days, and to take some additional leave. This was helpful not only for study but for the neccessary breaks that the change of season brings to the river.

Waimakariri

Source of Life: Knowledge and gaining new knowlege are vital to me in maintaining a healthy life. sometimes, like with water from the river, I can get a bit flooded, but to cut myself off from study of some kind would be unthinkable. Change is so much part of all aspects of our lives, but now I know more how to engage with it in the educational setting. There have been personal gains (I know much more theory mow to underpin my practice) and losses (I missed spending time with my husband).

Hawaii

Reaches the Sea: So we made it to the end. I hope that everyone who began was able to finish, but I know how hard that would have been, so am thinking of everyone who journeyed even part of the way together on this course. We were so well able to inspire each other at times of need. I am tired but keen to increasingly observe how the changes that I have made to my own practice will become more apparent in the time ahead. Thanks, everyone - I needed you and you were there.


Hobart

And our lecturers who monitored the rivers every step of the way, searching as intently as this bear is for his fish, they encouraged us, altered our course if required and kept the river clean from rubbish and sediment. I learned from you, so thanks, Wayne and Nicki, you made this an extraordinary learning experience.


Alaska

So, change with digital technologies in education: according to the course outline, I have now "discover[ed] principles and approaches that prompt complex changes affecting society and education today and explore[d] their roles in leadership and change. This course has three complementary elements: technology diffusion, shared leadership and models of change.I have also "gain[ed] experience as a change agent using digital technologies reflectively and responsibly to support educational change. (http://www.canterbury.ac.nz/courseinfo/GetCourseDetails.aspx?course=EDEM630&occurrence=13S2%28D%29&year=2013) 
And it is so, and it is good.

Alaska


All photographs were taken by me at various rivers in the past 5 years. And just because I can, here is one more view of the Waimakariri. The braiding is very much part of this course.

Waimakariri

Final music: this last fortnight, I've had a real variety of music as I spent a week with relations in Nelson and expanded my normal listening fare. My greatest pleasure was to hear One Notch Higher, a Nelson Rockquest band at one of their live practices. (https://www.facebook.com/OneNotchHigher?ref=stream)




Sunday, 21 July 2013

Arena of Change and maybe a mind-map

I've been watching videos and doing reading about the 'arena of change'. This is a theoretical model showing the wide range of influences that interact on a particular activity or action conducted by a teacher in a classroom. I have had to modify the thinking slightly as I do not have a classroom or a teacher in my research topic. However, the idea that the area of research is behaving in a stable way until the introduction of the change with digital technology is still completely true. The idea that there are nested influences acting with particular strength on the key species in the ecosystem is also fine with my question. So, the question wording remains the same as last week:

When two groups of staff in a New Zealand tertiary educational institution with differing perspectives and philosophies on the relative amounts of use of face to face and digital modes  in educational support provision are brought together structurally as a team, do changes ensue in use of and attitude to the balance of f2f and digital in the combined team? If so, in what areas does change occur?

The strongest players here are the people in the Learning, Teaching and Research team, who are influencing each other around changes in use of digital technologies. The relative strengths of that influence wax and wane depending on the areas where the technology is being applied. I think they/we are the keystone species. Everyone brought their own philosophy of teaching and beliefs around the merits of digital use, and each of the groups that were combined also had its own identity, which included policies and procedures around how to communicate and work with staff and students. Some is codified and some is past practice. This is where the change is happening. Our relative levels of experience of different technologies drive our engagement. E.g. in the LMS, Website, Repositories, digital identity/persona issues, curriculum development etc.

Next most influential is the professional corner of the arena. As a mixed team, we are related to and influenced by a vast array of professional organisations. These are all at slightly different levels of engagement, but they are where we draw the basis for our philosophical approaches, and to reflect on directions. In no particular order and not at all comprehensively, they include: academic staff and other wider university colleagues, HERDSA, LIANZA, ATLAANZ, TEU, ACODE, CTA, Core Education, Ako Aotearoa, EDUCAUSE, professional blogs and reading such as the LinkedIn fora, other conferences such as HETL...

Whether Commercial/IT is more influential than bureaucratic has caused me some issues. One the one hand, they are our other professional colleagues and sort of fit in the category above, but then there are the vendors like Catalyst or NZ Micrographics, and our other database and software vendors, and the communities around them, like the Moodle community. These people all provide additional support and influence direction, either because a system change dictates an alternative approach or because of the wider commercial environment that they introduce us to.

In the bureaucratic corner lives the impetus that brought the team together in the first place, (institutional requirements based on a number of factors, including financial) as well as the university policies and procedures, university strategies, and university expectations e.g. those defined in our change proposal. In this corner, the Tertiary Education Commission, CUAP, Universities New Zealand also come to bear as the small institution is expected by government to still offer the same range of services and level of student achievement and to operate at surplus.

Less influential factors that are definitely present are political (e.g. Universities Act, Copyright Act, Public Records Act), our relationship with the runanga (Taumutu), ongoing drivers from government in relation to co-operation within the Canterbury Tertiary Alliance since the earthquakes, the pressures of global competition, relationship with the Lincoln township and other community groups etc.


I'm still busy constructing the mind map. I was using MindMeister on my iPad, as this was one of the tools that I investigated during first semester last year in EDEM627. However, having spent some time working with the map, it kept having errors and saving new versions. Clearly, I needed to keep practicing with it, and, well, I haven't. Don't want to give up on a technological solution, though I do love getting down with the paper and the felt tips. Will try using Word or Powerpoint and see where that gets me. Will edit this post once it is done.
OK, here's the mindmap...


 Have now also read Niki's reply to forum posts, including mine, but guess that has confused me more, as I think she is saying that the arena model does not apply unless there are learners who are separate from the influential species i.e. that the two cannot be the same.However, I am going with this as it stands, at least for this week. Will amend as I understand more.
The video below is actually relevant to the week and to my research topic, but it is also very cool in its own right...


Cannot find the original citation details of "Herding Cats" but this version comes from YouTube where it is searchable and several versions are there.