Showing posts with label research topic. Show all posts
Showing posts with label research topic. Show all posts

Saturday, 27 July 2013

Provisional Essay Plan


For my topic, I am still staying with whether being in a combined team of professionals from different professional backgrounds affects how we interact with digital technologies. My current view is that the scope of my research question is too wide, in terms of the attitudes towards the balance of f2f and digital, and that I will need to stick to the changes in use for the most part and only use a few examples of digital technologies to examine and illustrate findings and conclusions. For this essay I will probably just use Yammer as an example,  though I have three other areas in mind as well. Also, because the essay question quite specifically requires practical implications for learners and teachers, I need to build in something that says that I have teachers and learners, even if they are both internal and external. The Yammer example probably works best for that requirement.
Here is the essay question:
The aim of this essay is to demonstrate your knowledge on a model(s) of change to answer a key question related to your own personal change context in order to demonstrate your ability to apply theory to inform practice.
Prepare an academic essay of 2000 - 3500 words reviewing a change model(s) and applying the literature to your own personal context with reference to an imminent or recent change with digital technology in education. Your essay should reference practical implications for learners and teachers, i.e. the personal or internal "classroom" context. 

 My goal for writing tbis essay is to gain insight into the ways that technology innovations are interacted with, and affect the team of which I am a part. I hope to learn more about how using a model can help me study, interpret and comprehend the changes that happen. It would also be good if the use of a model pointed me toward ways of improving our current practice. I want to deliver a coherent essay within the word limit and observing the points in the rubric.

The information to be included relates to the three questions provided for us in the key points on the assignment webpage. It says:

Change with digital technology involves three key questions:
  1. What is the change (technology innovation)?
  2. Why is the change important / necessary?
  3. How does the change impact on teachers and learners drawing on the published literature on change models to understand the implications of change with digital technology? 
 Therefore, I am planning to include answers to the what, why and how questions as they relate to my change context. The instructions also say that this is to be a concise review essay, so I need to keep in mind that too much information will not be acceptable -i.e. not my normal amount of rambling.

Essay Structure
Abstract - will probably draft this first, as it gives me the chance to summarise for myself what I think I am doing, and then finalise it after completion of the rest of the essay.
Introduction - explain the context and the changes, first to the team and then the technological change.
Model  -  talk about CBAM 
Model 2 - talk about Diffusion of Innovation (and maybe also LAT and TAM briefly to mention why I wont use them in this essay)
Application of the models -  talk about the two models in terms of the team
Practical Implications - talk about the way the technology has been applied
Conclusion - not far enough through yet to know what my conclusions will be, but I anticipate that at least one will be around the spread along the continuum of Rogers' diffusion model.


As mentioned, I will concentrate on the changes in the use of and the attitudes to use of digital technology and what that means for the adoption of it in the personal context of the LTaR team.

Music listened to while creating this blog post: Jack Johnson In Between Deams

Sunday, 21 July 2013

Arena of Change and maybe a mind-map

I've been watching videos and doing reading about the 'arena of change'. This is a theoretical model showing the wide range of influences that interact on a particular activity or action conducted by a teacher in a classroom. I have had to modify the thinking slightly as I do not have a classroom or a teacher in my research topic. However, the idea that the area of research is behaving in a stable way until the introduction of the change with digital technology is still completely true. The idea that there are nested influences acting with particular strength on the key species in the ecosystem is also fine with my question. So, the question wording remains the same as last week:

When two groups of staff in a New Zealand tertiary educational institution with differing perspectives and philosophies on the relative amounts of use of face to face and digital modes  in educational support provision are brought together structurally as a team, do changes ensue in use of and attitude to the balance of f2f and digital in the combined team? If so, in what areas does change occur?

The strongest players here are the people in the Learning, Teaching and Research team, who are influencing each other around changes in use of digital technologies. The relative strengths of that influence wax and wane depending on the areas where the technology is being applied. I think they/we are the keystone species. Everyone brought their own philosophy of teaching and beliefs around the merits of digital use, and each of the groups that were combined also had its own identity, which included policies and procedures around how to communicate and work with staff and students. Some is codified and some is past practice. This is where the change is happening. Our relative levels of experience of different technologies drive our engagement. E.g. in the LMS, Website, Repositories, digital identity/persona issues, curriculum development etc.

Next most influential is the professional corner of the arena. As a mixed team, we are related to and influenced by a vast array of professional organisations. These are all at slightly different levels of engagement, but they are where we draw the basis for our philosophical approaches, and to reflect on directions. In no particular order and not at all comprehensively, they include: academic staff and other wider university colleagues, HERDSA, LIANZA, ATLAANZ, TEU, ACODE, CTA, Core Education, Ako Aotearoa, EDUCAUSE, professional blogs and reading such as the LinkedIn fora, other conferences such as HETL...

Whether Commercial/IT is more influential than bureaucratic has caused me some issues. One the one hand, they are our other professional colleagues and sort of fit in the category above, but then there are the vendors like Catalyst or NZ Micrographics, and our other database and software vendors, and the communities around them, like the Moodle community. These people all provide additional support and influence direction, either because a system change dictates an alternative approach or because of the wider commercial environment that they introduce us to.

In the bureaucratic corner lives the impetus that brought the team together in the first place, (institutional requirements based on a number of factors, including financial) as well as the university policies and procedures, university strategies, and university expectations e.g. those defined in our change proposal. In this corner, the Tertiary Education Commission, CUAP, Universities New Zealand also come to bear as the small institution is expected by government to still offer the same range of services and level of student achievement and to operate at surplus.

Less influential factors that are definitely present are political (e.g. Universities Act, Copyright Act, Public Records Act), our relationship with the runanga (Taumutu), ongoing drivers from government in relation to co-operation within the Canterbury Tertiary Alliance since the earthquakes, the pressures of global competition, relationship with the Lincoln township and other community groups etc.


I'm still busy constructing the mind map. I was using MindMeister on my iPad, as this was one of the tools that I investigated during first semester last year in EDEM627. However, having spent some time working with the map, it kept having errors and saving new versions. Clearly, I needed to keep practicing with it, and, well, I haven't. Don't want to give up on a technological solution, though I do love getting down with the paper and the felt tips. Will try using Word or Powerpoint and see where that gets me. Will edit this post once it is done.
OK, here's the mindmap...


 Have now also read Niki's reply to forum posts, including mine, but guess that has confused me more, as I think she is saying that the arena model does not apply unless there are learners who are separate from the influential species i.e. that the two cannot be the same.However, I am going with this as it stands, at least for this week. Will amend as I understand more.
The video below is actually relevant to the week and to my research topic, but it is also very cool in its own right...


Cannot find the original citation details of "Herding Cats" but this version comes from YouTube where it is searchable and several versions are there.

More Thoughts of Blogs

So, the end of Week Two and I have not completed all the tasks...
I feel more friendly towards the thought of this blog now, even though in terms of published output it is not at the same level as last week. Conversing with work colleagues who blog regularly, my take-away message has been that you can actually edit until you are happy with what goes out, it is not vital to put the post up the same day you write it, so that can mean fewer but more coherent posts. Actually, and as usual, I am not editing this post at all, other than to check for spelling or really obvious errors, and I plan to hit publish very shortly, but my substantive post for the week has been on the go since Thursday, and has not yet seen the light of day.(Mind you, having a pounding head and profoundly dripping nose for all of Friday and Saturday hasn't helped the process of learning at all).
I like the analytics that Blogger has provided. I know where in the world my readers are based, and what sort of browser they use to access my page. I've learnt that replying to other people's blogs is generally best done in a good light, as you need to read and interpret those nasty graphics that check if you are a human or not. I've learnt that in exactly the same way as on the course forum, it is great to get feedback from others - thanks, Lesley for your forum post to me the other day :-)
I really can't finish exercise 2.1 today, and need to spend a bit more time finding a change model with which I am comfortable, or change my topic. I checked my topic with the team and have not received any negative feedback on it, so would quite like to keep going with that one if possible.
So, that will do on the reflection side, back to finishing a mindmap and publishing the other post for the week.

Not listening to any music today, as still have the residual pounding from 2 days of headache...

Sunday, 14 July 2013

Selecting a Research Topic - the Result

After looking at many of the topics that others have chosen and reading feedback from the week, I have decided to go with the more complex issue of the two I had narrowed down to. So now to answer the questions in learning activity 1.2 in 400 words:

  • STATE your research topic and identify the specific digital technology (or technologies). 
When two groups of staff in a New Zealand tertiary educational institution with differing perspectives and philosophies on the relative amounts of use of face to face and digital modes  in educational support provision are brought together structurally as a team, do changes ensue in use of and attitude to the balance of f2f and digital in the combined team? If so, in what areas does change occur?

There could be a number of digital technologies here, including learning management system, staff professional development workshops, website content etc. etc.
  • WHY did you choose the topic? What interests you about it? Do you have an opinion about the issues involved? 
I chose this topic as I manage a team in which this merging has happened, and we have been observing some behaviours that may be integrally related to the topic of this course: change with digital technologies in education. I am generally interested in the ability of the team to operate, relationships between pedagogy and technology, how someone's philosophy of teaching affects their engagement with the digital environment, whether the adoption of digital solutions can influence or change a philosophy, and many other aspects. My opinion is that there are very many issues involved, and I would like to see if this investigation teases some of them out for further consideration.
  • WHO are the information providers on this topic? Who might publish information about it? Who is affected by the topic? Do you know of organizations or institutions affiliated with the topic? 
 Ako Aotearoa should be a useful information provider, especially on the aspects around New Zealand tertiary sector, as one of their strategic themes is 'Promoting discussion and debate about the enhancement of tertiary teaching and learning.' I expect there will also be scholarly literature about the integration of teams, about the elements of change and about development of digital technology use. As there seems to be a trend for combining and recombining various combinations of educational support teams in New Zealand tertiary institutions, any NZ tertiary could potentially be affected by this topic. The institution that I propose to focus on is Lincoln University, and specifically the Learning, Teaching and Research team within Library, Teaching and Learning. Already, parts of this team are reflecting on the processes and outcomes of merging, and this research topic is an aspect of that wider contemplation. In choosing this topic, I acknowledge that further conversation with the team will need to occur in terms of what might be discussed in public on this blog as opposed to just submitted for course assessment purposes.


WHAT are the major questions for this topic? Is there a debate about the topic? Are there a range of issues and viewpoints to consider?
Some of the major questions have been referred to above under what interests me about the topic. Another question would be around the significance of such changes to the  team. I have already read that there several theoretical models around educator attitudes to technology, so I expect that determining an appropriate model may create some of the questions.
  • WHERE is your topic important: at the local, national or international level? Are there specific places affected by the topic? 
This topic is important to me, but if some generalisation could be made from the investigation and conclusions, it could potentially be significant to a wider audience. As mentioned above, I am asking the research question generally about NZ tertiary institutions, but intend to focus on one specific team when providing examples for analysis.
  • WHEN is/was your topic important? Is it a current event or an historical issue? Do you want to compare your topic by time periods? 
I intend to consider a couple of snapshot time periods prior to merging as the base from the change can be perceived but it is an ongoing current event.


Music listened to while creating this blog post: Rogers & Hammerstein's South Pacific.


Saturday, 13 July 2013

Selecting a Research topic - the process

OK, time for blogpost two. This is further than I have ever been before in blog life.
Our task for this post is to talk about our research topic for this course and it is to be a topic that encompasses change with digital technologies in education.
Over the course of the week, I moved from one topic to another, as I found articles that were in various ways related to my original idea but seemed more absorbing. I still kept to the plan of using a research topic that would inform my work. This adds value for me, and potentially for others.
So now I am down to two possibilities:
  • The role of ITS and Library, Teaching and Learning in influencing lecturers' adoption and use of lecture capture and streaming capabilities at Lincoln University
  • When two groups of educational staff with differing perspectives/philosophies on the amount/percentage of use of face to face and digital in service provision are brought together structurally as a team, what changes ensue in use of and attitude to the balance of f2f and digital? In what ways are the uses of technology related to the structural changes?
I am more excited about the possibilities in the second option, but focusing it could be more challenging too. I await feedback from my peers and lecturer, and in the meantime, I will seek to further inform the final decision by conducting a review of related literature. That is the bit I enjoy greatly, and, as mentioned above, I could spend many hours in that happy place.

Music listened to while creating this blog post: Queen - Greatest Hits.
A relevant link for this post seemed to be around the literature review... so here is one...


 
Defining The Literature Review (
Uploaded to YouTube on 13 Sep 2011
"This is a shorter version of the NCSU Libraries' video about the Literature Review Process. It is under a Creative Commons license. Category Education Licence Creative Commons Attribution licence (reuse allowed)"