Showing posts with label change. Show all posts
Showing posts with label change. Show all posts

Monday, 7 October 2013

How a River Runs - Final Course Reflection



When I am asked to name my river, e.g.as part of my mihi, I acknowledge the Waimakariri. It is a river that has so many different moods and aspects and I have engaged with it in very many of them. When I think about the whole of this course, there is a direct metaphoric relationship to a river and its journey to the sea. Each of the courses in the PG Dip have flowed in quite different ways, and mix at the end in the sea that is our educational practice and the relationship to all the other learning opportunities in our lives.

Direction: From the start we were provided with excellent direction via the course site. At the same time as our lecturers were giving us a detailed outline of the course, it was clear that as postgraduate students, we were to determine our own direction of study for assessment.

Denali National Park, Alaska


Flow: To begin with, I did not understand how the course would develop. l gradually learned the relevance of each aspect of the content, and was then able to settle in and flow through the exercises and readings. There were starts and stops for me as various other parts of life cut in, but I maintained engagement and was able to begin incorporation of what I was learning in my everyday work context.

Arthurs Pass


Depth: What illustrates depth the most is the impact on my practice that aspects of this course have given. In particular, the benchmarking and the scenario planning which were immediately applied to current projects. To start with, I found the ecological perspective really difficult, but rereading and getting the idea that it is actually not about ecology has permitted me to see how useful it is sitting alongside the arena of change. I had always believed that I operate within a tightly influenced and related world, this gave me a different way to view the way those influences could be incorporated. The river is deep and offers up its secrets gradually and only after effort.

Whanganui

Breadth: Just as a river can at times be wider, and at others, narrower, so it was with the technology requirements in this course. Changes with digital technology in education meant embracing the new. For me, that began with establishing a blog site, moved to engagement with mindmapping software, and, with the widest possible breadth I could cope with, into a mOOC, using wikieducator. I had to give up my reliance on my mobile devices which run on Apple software, and remember that I was part of a wider group - it was no longer all about me and what worked for me, but about what would work for the whole world. Now, I am happy that we had to blog, and really value the tangible record of my learning and my reactions to it.

Avon


Season: The expected amount of work in this course really surprised me. In hindsight, I had probably floated a bit in some of the other papers, but the realisation of what I needed to do to in order to engage and implement the learning led me to negotiate for my study days, and to take some additional leave. This was helpful not only for study but for the neccessary breaks that the change of season brings to the river.

Waimakariri

Source of Life: Knowledge and gaining new knowlege are vital to me in maintaining a healthy life. sometimes, like with water from the river, I can get a bit flooded, but to cut myself off from study of some kind would be unthinkable. Change is so much part of all aspects of our lives, but now I know more how to engage with it in the educational setting. There have been personal gains (I know much more theory mow to underpin my practice) and losses (I missed spending time with my husband).

Hawaii

Reaches the Sea: So we made it to the end. I hope that everyone who began was able to finish, but I know how hard that would have been, so am thinking of everyone who journeyed even part of the way together on this course. We were so well able to inspire each other at times of need. I am tired but keen to increasingly observe how the changes that I have made to my own practice will become more apparent in the time ahead. Thanks, everyone - I needed you and you were there.


Hobart

And our lecturers who monitored the rivers every step of the way, searching as intently as this bear is for his fish, they encouraged us, altered our course if required and kept the river clean from rubbish and sediment. I learned from you, so thanks, Wayne and Nicki, you made this an extraordinary learning experience.


Alaska

So, change with digital technologies in education: according to the course outline, I have now "discover[ed] principles and approaches that prompt complex changes affecting society and education today and explore[d] their roles in leadership and change. This course has three complementary elements: technology diffusion, shared leadership and models of change.I have also "gain[ed] experience as a change agent using digital technologies reflectively and responsibly to support educational change. (http://www.canterbury.ac.nz/courseinfo/GetCourseDetails.aspx?course=EDEM630&occurrence=13S2%28D%29&year=2013) 
And it is so, and it is good.

Alaska


All photographs were taken by me at various rivers in the past 5 years. And just because I can, here is one more view of the Waimakariri. The braiding is very much part of this course.

Waimakariri

Final music: this last fortnight, I've had a real variety of music as I spent a week with relations in Nelson and expanded my normal listening fare. My greatest pleasure was to hear One Notch Higher, a Nelson Rockquest band at one of their live practices. (https://www.facebook.com/OneNotchHigher?ref=stream)




Saturday, 10 August 2013

Scenario Matrix - Better Late then Never

This week the struggle has been not only with absorption and processing of content but also with the technology. I confess I don't know how to use graphics software. I know it would be a great advantage to be able to use it, but at work and in the rest of life, I know other people who can use it and love it and they do my diagrams when I need them. Tempting though it was, I did not ask anyone else to do it this time because this course is about us getting to grips with technology in educational settings. So anyway, producing the scenario matrix has been challenging, even getting my ideas to the stage where they could be put in to the diagram in the first place. I had a mental block because each part of the task seemed challenging, so in total it looked too much.  I was reassured that others were feeling the same and certainly did not want to give up.


The two axes are uncertainties that I gleaned from separate sources.
EduPunk to Edubusiness came from Steve Wheeler's blog this week and it relates to the tension between formal learning and DIY learning. Some of the uncertainties on our questionstorm are related to this one, I think. It is very important to the future as many of our learning tools and their underlying principles are being purchased and packaged by businesses. In my context it is uncertain because of the tension between ease of use/funding and principles/timing/convenience.
Formal Assessment to Informal Credentialing came from Terry Anderson's video signpost and relates both to authentication of learning and to the structure/nature of assessment. It is important in my context with the increased moves to internationalsation and to blended teaching/delivery. It is 'certainly uncertain' because there are pressures/drivers that could tip it either way.




Sunday, 28 July 2013

First Official Reflection on Course Learning

Ok, the challenge is to reflect for 500 to 800 words. Since the reflection is the most difficult part of the course for me, this could be too much. I chose to call my blog Reflections on Learning because I knew this would be expected of us, and I wanted to remind myself that it needed to be done.

One. Thinking about how my prior experience may be affecting my views of the course by doing comparison and contrast with other recent learning:
Coming off only doing 15 points in Semester One, and doing that course in between urgent work deadlines has meant a radical shift for me in terms of viewing this course. This course requires more work (well obviously!)and much more engagement with the process as well as the content. My Semester One course was offered in online and f2f mode but the online was really just watching and listening to the recordings and power-points then doing what the others had done in class. I went to one face to face class and found it much more engaging than working alone in the online mode. This course has genuine online engagement and the mode and pace of interaction has been carefully considered and planned. It is more like the two courses I took last year. My prior experience and my work experience have not involved the use of wikieducator but have been very much based in using an LMS and websites. Therefore, I found it difficult to accept that making the course more inclusive for others in other parts of the world meant making it more difficult for me. (Egocentric but true). I had been used to working towards making online offerings device agnostic and therefore avoiding the use of frames, and flash and trying to use HTML5. So my prior experience led me to think I would be able to use my iPad a lot more than has been possible. In particular, I cannot view videos there and this has meant a more disjointed learning experience, as my partner and I have to share the PC, which he often needs to do some work on in the evenings, too.

Two. Thinking about new content and its application:
In week one we made a blog, picked a topic and began an annotated bibliography. Making and using a blog was the only part of this that I was unfamiliar with, and I reflected on that previously  in my introduction blog. Picking a topic, as others have commented on, was hard when we were doing it in a vacuum and really only had the title of the course and the assessment tasks to go from. I wished to have a topic that was relevant to work and that I already wanted to know the answers to or wider viewpoints on. Although I like my current topic, it doesn't really fit too well with what we started to look at in Week two - the ecological approach and arena model. That approach applies quite well in my personal experience, just that I am not in the playing field but in the stands. It has been helpful to share with the rest of the class and see where each person sees themselves fitting. I have been surprised by the people who had not realised until applying this approach that what they did in their classroom could affect a wide variety of other stakeholders, though they know that other stakeholders affected them. I guess I juggle that to various degrees all day. I hear from students, teachers, IT professionals, our own group, senior management, parents, other professionals etc., on various aspects of the same topic or project so it  feels far too interconnected to me sometimes. The arena model in a way reminds me of the butterfly effect. Yes, I am quoting wikipedia, and for a quick introductory overview, I think that is appropriate even in a postgraduate course. I am impressed that we have as one of our lecturers such an experienced educational thinker who can form elegant models and theories. I feel fortunate that Niki and Wayne are the ones taking us through this content and I love that we get prompt feedback on where we are going individually as well as summaries for us as a group. In terms of applying content, I have found this week's models fascinating and have already begun to test their application in work I am doing. They ring true so far, and I suspect that my preferences for some models over others is based  on being not very task oriented but very strongly people oriented in my approach. I will have to be careful not to let this bias interfere with chosing the most applicable theoretical framework.

Three. My questions:
Can I spend enough time interacting with the rest of the class? I like it when we all answer a question on the forum, as then I get a real feeling that we are all in this together and can start to see our common and different views and knowledge. Going in and out of the blogs is too messy for my mind to collate this holistic view. Maybe we will do this in the MOOC bit in the next weeks?
 Do we get to read each other's essays? This follows on from my first question.

 So there it is... first official reflection...

Music listened to while preparing this blog post: Monday, Monday by The Mamas and The Papas. (because we are singing this in the Lincoln University Campus Choir at present, and there is a particular note I don't get). Got to multitask :-)



Saturday, 27 July 2013

Provisional Essay Plan


For my topic, I am still staying with whether being in a combined team of professionals from different professional backgrounds affects how we interact with digital technologies. My current view is that the scope of my research question is too wide, in terms of the attitudes towards the balance of f2f and digital, and that I will need to stick to the changes in use for the most part and only use a few examples of digital technologies to examine and illustrate findings and conclusions. For this essay I will probably just use Yammer as an example,  though I have three other areas in mind as well. Also, because the essay question quite specifically requires practical implications for learners and teachers, I need to build in something that says that I have teachers and learners, even if they are both internal and external. The Yammer example probably works best for that requirement.
Here is the essay question:
The aim of this essay is to demonstrate your knowledge on a model(s) of change to answer a key question related to your own personal change context in order to demonstrate your ability to apply theory to inform practice.
Prepare an academic essay of 2000 - 3500 words reviewing a change model(s) and applying the literature to your own personal context with reference to an imminent or recent change with digital technology in education. Your essay should reference practical implications for learners and teachers, i.e. the personal or internal "classroom" context. 

 My goal for writing tbis essay is to gain insight into the ways that technology innovations are interacted with, and affect the team of which I am a part. I hope to learn more about how using a model can help me study, interpret and comprehend the changes that happen. It would also be good if the use of a model pointed me toward ways of improving our current practice. I want to deliver a coherent essay within the word limit and observing the points in the rubric.

The information to be included relates to the three questions provided for us in the key points on the assignment webpage. It says:

Change with digital technology involves three key questions:
  1. What is the change (technology innovation)?
  2. Why is the change important / necessary?
  3. How does the change impact on teachers and learners drawing on the published literature on change models to understand the implications of change with digital technology? 
 Therefore, I am planning to include answers to the what, why and how questions as they relate to my change context. The instructions also say that this is to be a concise review essay, so I need to keep in mind that too much information will not be acceptable -i.e. not my normal amount of rambling.

Essay Structure
Abstract - will probably draft this first, as it gives me the chance to summarise for myself what I think I am doing, and then finalise it after completion of the rest of the essay.
Introduction - explain the context and the changes, first to the team and then the technological change.
Model  -  talk about CBAM 
Model 2 - talk about Diffusion of Innovation (and maybe also LAT and TAM briefly to mention why I wont use them in this essay)
Application of the models -  talk about the two models in terms of the team
Practical Implications - talk about the way the technology has been applied
Conclusion - not far enough through yet to know what my conclusions will be, but I anticipate that at least one will be around the spread along the continuum of Rogers' diffusion model.


As mentioned, I will concentrate on the changes in the use of and the attitudes to use of digital technology and what that means for the adoption of it in the personal context of the LTaR team.

Music listened to while creating this blog post: Jack Johnson In Between Deams

Sunday, 14 July 2013

First Items for Annotated Bibliography



And since it is Sunday afternoon and therefore almost the end of week one, I now need to post the first items in my annotated bibliography. I have already discovered that retaining font and layout when cutting and pasting into Blogger is not the most reliable, so will give the APA my best shot from scratch...

Govender, D. W. (2012). A model to predict educators' attitudes towards technology and  thus technology adoption.  Africa Education Review, 9(3), 548-568. DOI: 10.1080/18146627.2012.741101

Description:This journal article looks at a number of models and variables related to educators' attitudes to technology and its incorporation for teaching and learning. Using secondary school educators in a region of KwaZuluNatal, the author distributed a questionnaire that was then analysed using SPSS. Several areas are identified as significant including educators' vision of technology and their perceptions of its usefulness.The author also concludes that there is a need for teachers to experiment and be supported before using technology in the classroom.

Evaluation: The article summaries several relevant theoretical models of change and this is helpful to me in establishing a model for my own research. The article reference list has already led me to further useful reading. Desmond Govender is researching in his own geographical area as I also expect to do.

Bates, A. W., & Sangra,A. (2011). Managing technology in higher education: Strategies for transforming teaching and learning. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass.

Description: This book looks at incorporating technology into learning and teaching in an international context in the tertiary sector. It provides details of practice (case-study-type examples) that were current at the time the book was prepared (early 2011).

Evaluation: Bates is highly regarded for his writing around using technology to improve the quality of teaching. Though some of cases are now 3 years out of date, the content is practical and comprehensive. The book has a particular focus on change and Chapter 8: Barriers to Change and Two Ways to Remove Them will be useful for my research. That chapter has a particular focus on organisational culture within the university, and around teaching and training for teaching.


Well, I have failed to get the required indentation for the second line of wrapped text as required by APA. Partially consoled that when I look at other people's blogs they haven't either but will be keen to learn how it should be done in this environment...

Music listened to while preparing this blog post: April McLean Everything's Gonna Change, Head over Heels and Becoming.
 

Selecting a Research Topic - the Result

After looking at many of the topics that others have chosen and reading feedback from the week, I have decided to go with the more complex issue of the two I had narrowed down to. So now to answer the questions in learning activity 1.2 in 400 words:

  • STATE your research topic and identify the specific digital technology (or technologies). 
When two groups of staff in a New Zealand tertiary educational institution with differing perspectives and philosophies on the relative amounts of use of face to face and digital modes  in educational support provision are brought together structurally as a team, do changes ensue in use of and attitude to the balance of f2f and digital in the combined team? If so, in what areas does change occur?

There could be a number of digital technologies here, including learning management system, staff professional development workshops, website content etc. etc.
  • WHY did you choose the topic? What interests you about it? Do you have an opinion about the issues involved? 
I chose this topic as I manage a team in which this merging has happened, and we have been observing some behaviours that may be integrally related to the topic of this course: change with digital technologies in education. I am generally interested in the ability of the team to operate, relationships between pedagogy and technology, how someone's philosophy of teaching affects their engagement with the digital environment, whether the adoption of digital solutions can influence or change a philosophy, and many other aspects. My opinion is that there are very many issues involved, and I would like to see if this investigation teases some of them out for further consideration.
  • WHO are the information providers on this topic? Who might publish information about it? Who is affected by the topic? Do you know of organizations or institutions affiliated with the topic? 
 Ako Aotearoa should be a useful information provider, especially on the aspects around New Zealand tertiary sector, as one of their strategic themes is 'Promoting discussion and debate about the enhancement of tertiary teaching and learning.' I expect there will also be scholarly literature about the integration of teams, about the elements of change and about development of digital technology use. As there seems to be a trend for combining and recombining various combinations of educational support teams in New Zealand tertiary institutions, any NZ tertiary could potentially be affected by this topic. The institution that I propose to focus on is Lincoln University, and specifically the Learning, Teaching and Research team within Library, Teaching and Learning. Already, parts of this team are reflecting on the processes and outcomes of merging, and this research topic is an aspect of that wider contemplation. In choosing this topic, I acknowledge that further conversation with the team will need to occur in terms of what might be discussed in public on this blog as opposed to just submitted for course assessment purposes.


WHAT are the major questions for this topic? Is there a debate about the topic? Are there a range of issues and viewpoints to consider?
Some of the major questions have been referred to above under what interests me about the topic. Another question would be around the significance of such changes to the  team. I have already read that there several theoretical models around educator attitudes to technology, so I expect that determining an appropriate model may create some of the questions.
  • WHERE is your topic important: at the local, national or international level? Are there specific places affected by the topic? 
This topic is important to me, but if some generalisation could be made from the investigation and conclusions, it could potentially be significant to a wider audience. As mentioned above, I am asking the research question generally about NZ tertiary institutions, but intend to focus on one specific team when providing examples for analysis.
  • WHEN is/was your topic important? Is it a current event or an historical issue? Do you want to compare your topic by time periods? 
I intend to consider a couple of snapshot time periods prior to merging as the base from the change can be perceived but it is an ongoing current event.


Music listened to while creating this blog post: Rogers & Hammerstein's South Pacific.